CMC Podcast EP. 32 | ITRS and Testing Bias

By CMC Rescue, Inc.

· 1 min. read

CMC instructors Craig McClure and Justin Wheaton discuss rigorous testing methodologies and peer review processes that advance technical rope rescue practices. The episode explores how confirmation bias influences research and why failed tests often yield the most valuable insights. The hosts advocate for diverse perspectives and new voices at industry symposiums to drive innovation and safety improvements.

Key points

  • Meaningful testing pushes systems to failure to understand limits. Craig explains that effective research focuses on discovering why systems succeed or fail, rather than validating existing beliefs about rope rescue equipment.
  • Early testing was influenced by commercial and instructional bias. Craig and Justin's multi-year research on small-diameter rope systems revealed how industry and educational perspectives initially shaped their methodology and assumptions.
  • Effective research often changes the original question asked. The hosts emphasize that following results wherever they lead requires willingness to adapt research direction and "a willingness to follow results wherever they lead."
  • Confirmation bias and peer challenge are critical to validation. Trusted colleagues questioning assumptions during testing helps identify blind spots and strengthens the integrity of rope rescue research and equipment evaluation.
  • Failed tests provide the most valuable information. Unexpected outcomes from rope systems, anchors, and rescue equipment testing often reveal essential safety data that successful tests cannot demonstrate.
  • ITRS needs diverse voices beyond traditional rescue perspectives. Craig expresses concern about symposium dominance by recurring presenters and advocates for new disciplines, human-factor research, leadership training, and psychology-focused presentations in the rescue community.

Summarized by MalakyeAI

Links Cited on this Page