A healthcare researcher examines claims that a specific compound called 2-nonenal causes "old person smell" and that persimmon soap eliminates 97% of it. The scientific evidence supporting these marketing claims is surprisingly weak, relying on a single 2001 study of just 22 people sponsored by a cosmetic company. Multiple factors—including reduced bathing frequency, oral health issues, urinary incontinence, and medical conditions—better explain age-related body odor changes.
Key points
- A 2001 study identified 2-nonenal as a possible age-related odor contributor. Researchers at a Japanese cosmetics company found the compound showed "a tendency to increase with aging" in a small group, but almost no peer-reviewed studies have investigated the claim since then.
- The scientific evidence for 2-nonenal causing "old person smell" remains tentative. "One company is making the claim on the internet that 'old person smell' is caused by one compound," yet robust data supporting this singular connection does not exist.
- Persimmon soap companies claim their products remove up to 97% of nonenal without public evidence. The cited testing data from a Japanese partner lab is not available for peer-reviewed scientific scrutiny or public examination.
- A 2012 study tested persimmon soap combined with other plant extracts but lacked proper controls. The research involved only 20 men and could not determine whether persimmon specifically caused improvements or whether regular daily washing alone would have produced similar results.
- Regular soap removes surface lipids and odor compounds effectively through routine bathing. Since 2-nonenal forms from oxidized skin oils, daily showering with ordinary soap should remove both the material that creates the compound and any accumulation already present.
- Multiple factors contribute to age-related body odor beyond any single chemical compound. Decreased bathing frequency, poor oral hygiene, urinary incontinence, unwashed clothing, medications, diet, and underlying medical conditions all significantly affect how older adults smell.
Summarized by MalakyeAI
