Quest Nutrition misleadingly promotes its products as healthy, a new class action lawsuit alleges.
By Claim Depot

Sue Colby filed a class action lawsuit against Quest Nutrition on Sept. 23, 2026, alleging the company misleadingly markets protein bars, cookies and candy as healthy while sweetening them with erythritol, a sugar alcohol linked to cardiovascular risks. The lawsuit targets at least 45 Quest products sold in nutrition and sports-nutrition aisles. Colby seeks damages and a court order requiring Quest to halt challenged marketing practices.
Key points
- Quest Nutrition allegedly markets products with misleading health claims despite using erythritol. The company promotes snacks as high-protein, low-sugar options with "only quality ingredients" while retailers stock them alongside legitimate health products.
- A 2023 Cleveland Clinic study found erythritol-elevated blood levels roughly doubled heart attack and stroke risk within three years. Researchers discovered a single erythritol drink raised blood levels over 1,000-fold within minutes, maintaining levels high enough to affect platelet function for 48 hours.
- The lawsuit covers 28 protein bar flavors, 10 cookie varieties, four bake shop items and three candy products. Quest, a subsidiary of Simply Good Foods, sells these items at retailers including GNC and The Vitamin Shoppe.
- Plaintiff Sue Colby purchased a Quest chocolate chip cookie dough protein bar based on the brand's ingredient quality claims. She claims she would have "paid less or skipped the purchase" had she known the marketing was allegedly misleading.
- The complaint cites two additional studies linking erythritol to health concerns. A 2024 study found erythritol made platelets more reactive than glucose, while a 2025 University of Colorado Boulder study reportedly showed erythritol impaired cells lining the brain's small blood vessels.
- Four legal claims target California consumer protection and unjust enrichment laws. If Quest does not correct alleged violations within 30 days, Colby plans to pursue additional damages and seek a nationwide class certification.
Summarized by MalakyeAI