Why a Motion Skeptic Changed His Mind: Inside the Vincennes University Aviation Flight Program

Sean MacDermott initially dismissed motion simulation after Vincennes University's legacy devices performed poorly. A trial flight on a RealSimGear SR7x Pro simulator changed his perspective, demonstrating that motion's value lies in realistic distraction rather than sustained G-force replication. Vincennes has since built a six-device simulator lab with motion platforms to match its upgraded Cirrus fleet.
Key points
- Vincennes upgraded simulators to match its new Cirrus SR20 G7 aircraft fleet. The existing devices emulated outdated G3-era panels, causing students to distrust training value and move hours back to aircraft operations.
- Sean MacDermott pulled a CAPS parachute handle and "got so distracted by all of the motion" that he forgot subsequent procedures. This experience reversed his skepticism about motion platforms for instrument training.
- RealSimGear's software accuracy proved decisive in the vendor selection process. The competing device had superior build quality but "the software just was not there," with incorrect menu displays that would replicate the original problem.
- Motion platforms create realistic distractions that teach students to override false physical cues. In multi-engine training, students feel engine failure through airframe movement before seeing panel indications, matching real aircraft experience.
- Emulated avionics eliminate expensive line replaceable unit maintenance costs of approximately $10,000 per component. Ten instrument pilots trained primarily on the fixed-base device reported it performed identically to aircraft avionics.
- Students save substantial costs by completing 40 percent of instrument training on simulators at $75 per hour versus $230 in aircraft. An open lab staffed Monday through Thursday allows students unlimited practice at no additional fee, enabling four steep spiral repetitions in 30 minutes rather than two repetitions for $400.
Summarized by MalakyeAI