Songwriters drop ‘alright, alright, alright’ sample lawsuit against Travis Scott and Sony Music

Songwriters Dion Norman and Derrick Ordogne have voluntarily dismissed their nearly three-year copyright lawsuit against Travis Scott and Sony Music over alleged unauthorized sampling. The pair filed notice of dismissal on October 9 without prejudice, meaning they can refile the same claims later. The notice provided no details on whether a settlement was reached.
Key points
- Norman and Ordogne claimed Scott used an uncleared sample from their 1991 track "Bitches (Reply)." The sample allegedly appeared in Scott's "Stargazing" from his 2018 album Astroworld and "Til Further Notice" from 2023's Utopia, with "Stargazing" reaching No. 8 on the Billboard Hot 100.
- The disputed sample contained the vocal phrase "alright, alright, alright" with altered tone and pitch. The original complaint cited six timestamps in "Til Further Notice" and the 3:46 mark in "Stargazing" where the vocal allegedly appears.
- Defendants admitted to unauthorized use after Utopia's release, according to the second amended complaint. The complaint stated that "Defendants admitted to the unauthorized use of 'Bitches Reply' to the Plaintiffs when it had a sample clearance vendor contact the Plaintiffs via e-mail."
- The plaintiffs sought actual losses, profit shares, statutory damages, and punitive damages. They also requested a permanent order prohibiting reproduction and distribution of both Scott tracks on streaming services like Spotify and Apple Music.
- Scott's legal team argued the phrase lacked sufficient creativity for copyright protection. Lawyers contended that "the single word 'alright' and the short phrase 'alright, alright, alright' lack even the 'minimal creativity required for copyright protection.'"
- This dismissal follows another voluntary dismissal over a Scott track from Utopia. Singer-songwriter Victory Boyd dismissed her lawsuit against Scott, SZA, and Future over "Telekinesis" in June, though she dismissed with prejudice, preventing refiling.
Summarized by MalakyeAI