Cheer Sex-Abuse Suit Against Varsity, Webb Estate Needs a Restart
By Sportico.com

A federal judge in Georgia has ordered a former cheerleader alleging sexual abuse by her coach to replead her lawsuit against Varsity Brands and the estate of founder Jeff Webb. The ruling keeps the case alive despite significant procedural deficiencies. The $200 million suit represents the first legal action targeting Webb's estate following his death in March.
Key points
- Jane Doe alleges she was sexually abused by coach Charles Archibald Moore III. The unnamed victim claims she was "sexually abused, raped, drugged, harassed, violated, pornographically filmed and molested" by Moore, who was sentenced to 25 years in April.
- Judge Amy Totenberg found the original complaint contained material defects and lacked focus. She compared the plaintiffs' approach to "throwing spaghetti at the wall to see what sticks," citing numerous claims against 529 named and unnamed defendants.
- The judge questioned whether the plaintiffs' attorneys had adequate experience for complex federal litigation. Totenberg noted "somewhat slipshod handling of this case thus far" and encouraged the plaintiffs to hire attorneys specializing in sex-abuse cases rather than personal injury law.
- Totenberg declined to dismiss the case despite its procedural problems. Given the "gravity of the matter" and "concerning number of troubling allegations," the judge determined procedural issues should not prevent plaintiffs from seeking redress.
- Plaintiffs have 40 days to file a revised complaint addressing the deficiencies. The court will substantively address claims against Webb's estate after reviewing the new pleadings and the probate proceedings underway in Tennessee.
- This lawsuit follows Varsity's previous settlements with dozens of sex-abuse plaintiffs. Most prior cases involving cheer coaches were resolved by early 2024, before Varsity's acquisition by KKR.
Summarized by MalakyeAI