SURF: United States Supreme Court Ruling Upholds Public Beach Access Rights
TL;DR
United States Supreme Court Ruling Upholds Public Beach Access Rights The Surfrider Foundation won an important victory on June 17th when the United States Supreme Court unanimously ruled (with Justice Stevens abstaining) in Florida Department of Environmental Protection v.
United States Supreme Court Ruling Upholds Public Beach
Access Rights
The Surfrider Foundation won an important
victory on June 17th when the United States Supreme Court unanimously ruled
(with Justice Stevens abstaining) in Florida Department of Environmental
Protection v. Stop the Beach Renourishment to reject the challenge by private
homeowners, uphold the constitutionality of Florida’s beach management program,
and hold that the beach belongs to the public after beach renourishment has
occurred.
"The United States Supreme Court's decision
in this case solidifies the State's authority to act in the interest of the
public trust and secure their beach access rights,” says Angela Howe, Surfrider
Foundation’s Managing Attorney. “This decision will help inform courts and
legislatures in Texas, Hawaii, California, Oregon, and other places where the
Surfrider Foundation is actively fighting for beach access."
In
Florida Department of Environmental Protection v. Stop the Beach Renourishment,
petitioners asked the Court to endorse the judicial takings doctrine to prevent
the public from using the beach in front of the private property owner’s homes
once the beach had been renourished. This would have contradicted nearly
100 years of Supreme Court law on the issue as well as the Florida Supreme
Court, which interpreted the state’s common law that public beach access should
be protected in the best interest in of citizens in the state.
The
Supreme Court’s ruling states that anytime there is a beach renourishment
project in Florida, it is an “avulsive event,” meaning with the sudden addition
of sand, the normal rights of accretion of the private homeowners do not
apply. The taxpayer-funded sand belongs to and benefits the public and
will not be used for extensions of private beaches.
Surfrider
Foundation’s brief, written by an expert team of pro bono attorneys at
McDermott, Will & Emery LLP, argued that the state’s current regime properly
allocates the beach access rights to the public after any beach management or
restoration efforts have occurred. Specifically, our amicus brief argued
that the Florida beach access provisions of the beach management program are
constitutional on their face, that the private property owner’s private rights
are not affected by the Florida law, and that the Judicial Takings Doctrine of
the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment are not applicable in this case.
Furthermore, the Florida law at issue provides reasonable and appropriate
measures to enable the State of Florida to discharge its obligations to the
citizens of Florida as trustee, under Article X of the Florida Constitution, of
the public’s rights of access to the State’s lands to navigable
waters.
Additionally, the Surfrider Foundation’s Emerald Coast
Chapter supported the case by providing survey information on beach access use,
and members of the Chapter attended the Supreme Court hearing in Washington, DC
on December 2, 2009.
"This is a great decision for Surfrider,” says
Dan Foster, partner with McDermott, Will & Emery LLP. “We believe the
Supreme Court's decision is consistent with Surfrider's mission to promote the
protection and enjoyment of the world's oceans, waves and beaches for all
people. The decision should profoundly affect states' ability to maintain
and provide access to beaches for the public."